商家名称 | 信用等级 | 购买信息 | 订购本书 |
Metalworking - Doing it Better: Machining, Welding, Fabricating | |||
Metalworking - Doing it Better: Machining, Welding, Fabricating |
Acknowledgements; Introduction; Diving In; Brain Food; Bean Counter Lounge; Setting Up Your Shop; Manual Lathe; Manual Milling Machine; CNC Mill; CNC Lathe; The Welding Shop; The Lost Art of Flame Straightening; Sheet Metal Shop; The Abrasion Department; The Junk Drawer; Closing Thoughts; Recommended Reading List; Index.
网友对Metalworking - Doing it Better: Machining, Welding, Fabricating的评论
Really there are two ways to review this book. If you don't already have "Metalworking: Sink or Swim" it's really a five star book. I bought "Sink or Swim" several years ago and have constantly referred back to it. It's the only book I own that has so much solid information about machining, welding, and sheet metal work all in one volume. I also subscribe to Tom's YouTube channel, and there is a bunch of great information over there. I was hoping this would be another volume of new information.
The bad news is that 99% of the information contained in "Doing it Better" is exactly the same as what was in "Sink or Swim". The introduction is a little different, but you have to look pretty close to spot differences between the two. "Doing it Better" even has the same life preserver graphic on all the pages that was in "Sink or Swim."
So, if you don't have either of Tom's books, I would encourage the purchase of one or the other. Getting both is really not necessary.
I am currently reading this book. When I am finished with the first pass I will update this review. The book has information I want for my hobby, metalworking. The author is active in sharing his knowledge on YouTube, I like his approach, sense of humor, and respect for his trade. It is well reflected in what I have read so far. He discusses among other things the need to pass along what has been given to you, albeit more freely than it was given. Working in metal; designing, machining, and fabricating, is fascinating, and rewarding, well at least to me, to my wife not so much. The forth chapter on shop organization has made it well worth the price. This book is out in my shop right next to Machinery's Handbook. If metalworking is your trade or your hobby I will already endorse this as a good read and source of good ideas. (still reading)
2/27/2014
Here is the update: After finishing reading this book I would give it 6 stars if I could. I enjoyed reading it, the illustrations are clear and meaningful and the advice is practical. Buy Metalworking Doing it Better!, buy the Machinery's Handbook used, anything greater than the 19th edition (30th is the current).
The content of this book is very good and I know because I purchased Metalworking Sink or Swim. This is the same book with a new shinny cover. I fault the publisher for pulling essentially a bait and switch. If you do not have the other book this is a good buy, but Industrial Press wants you to buy two books that are the same.
This review is based on the Kindle version. Overall I found this to be a good book about metal working. The author has tips and food for thought on so many odds and ends that a second or third reading will be needed to catch them all. It is easy reading and I read the whole thing in just a few sittings. To me that is an indication of a good book, was it interesting and fun to read. I was a little disappointed there was not more insightful stuff about manual milling but there are other books on that subject. One of the little side bar stories in the book talked about remaining current with the times so we do not disappear like the ice cutters back in the day. I told my kids that one, it is just a good general life lesson and is one of the many gold nuggets of learning in the book. As a minor annoyance perhaps just with the Kindle version though is the book has a lot of great photos to illustrate the talking points, but the text and photos were almost always on opposite pages.
喜欢Metalworking - Doing it Better: Machining, Welding, Fabricating请与您的朋友分享,由于版权原因,读书人网不提供图书下载服务